Fix behaviour training or lose funding, universities told

Fix behaviour training or lose funding, universities told

In a speech setting out the Coalition’s approach to classroom behaviour on Thursday, Shadow Education Minister Julian Leeser proposed cutting off funding for universities that fail to prepare teachers for disruptive classrooms.

Speaking at an event hosted by the Centre for Independent Studies in Sydney, Leeser said patience with underperforming teacher education providers was wearing thin.

“It has been clear for years now that far too many teachers have been let down by their initial teacher education at university,” Leeser said. “Let me ask the basic question: if these universities do not meet the minimum standards for initial teacher education that have been agreed by Education Ministers, why are we funding them?”

Leeser said this is less about “beating up on teachers” and more about addressing the academic institutions which “refuse to give up faddish pet theories or ignore the evidence around best practice.”

“Almost 5 years ago the QITE review said that we should, quote, ‘strengthen the link between performance and funding of ITE’, and that we should allocate CSPs based on ITE performance,” he said. “It’s time to revisit that recommendation.”

One of the instruments through which this could happen in the immediate term, said Leeser, is a direction to the Australian Tertiary Education Commission (ATEC) around the preferential allocation of Commonwealth supported places to universities that effectively implement content around behaviour management and other core skills.

Leeser added that he is “open to other measures”, such as “beefing up” the ITE Quality Assurance Oversight Board, or establishing a National Inspector of ITE to stop the university leaders from “weaselling out of change.”

“If the universities responsible for training our teachers aren’t setting them up for success, aren’t giving Principals what they need, and aren’t even implementing basic standards around teacher training, why should Australian mums and dads keep paying for them?” he said.

“Let the message go forward to the universities: no phonics no funding.”

Is funding the right lever to pull?

Dr Bronwyn Reid O'Connor is a Senior Lecturer in Secondary Mathematics Education at the University of Sydney. She said that tying university funding to behaviour management content misses where the real problem lies.

“If we are serious about improving classroom behaviour, we need to invest in preparing and supporting teachers, not threaten to defund the universities training them,” Dr O’Connor said. “Universities should absolutely be accountable for preparing teachers to manage classrooms effectively.” 

However, Dr Connor said simply requiring every university to teach particular behaviour management strategies doesn't mean graduates will know how to use them effectively in real classrooms.

“Defunding teacher education programs risks reducing the very capacity we need to address teacher shortages and strengthen the profession.”