
In September the results from the 2025 Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) assessment found that Australian high school students' results in maths and reading hit their lowest point on record, continuing a 20-year decline.
A telling statistic from the report is that Aussie teens are twice as likely as their counterparts in peer nations to spend more than two hours per day learning on digital devices, reinforcing calls from experts to dial back the use of digital devices in classrooms.
In response, education ministers agreed on Monday 2 November to “introduce, trial or consider” limits on screen use in schools, and to restrict students’ use of generative AI in primary schools and secondary assessments. States, territories and school sectors will each decide how these measures are rolled out in their classrooms.
Ministers also agreed that Year 5 NAPLAN writing tests will return to pen and paper from 2028.
On Thursday 5 November, Federal Education Minister Jason Clare announced a new Australian Schools Digital Detox Taskforce to advise ministers on next steps. The taskforce will consult students, teachers, researchers and industry experts, and is expected to report back three times in 2027.
Yet the success of the proposed ‘digital detox’ will hinge less on how many minutes students spend on screens than on what changes as a result. As the Taskforce prepares to advise ministers, the real test will be deciding what counts as proof that it’s working.
‘Much more is needed’
Shadow Education Minister, Julian Leeser, said that while the changes are necessary, they’re “not sufficient.”
“They are steps in the right direction but will not improve performance on their own,” Leeser told The Educator.
“I am on the record arguing for reduction in screen time and AI use by students from my very first day in the education portfolio, based on neurocognitive effects. The same is not true of Jason Clare, and I am glad to see this change of heart.”
Leeser said returning to handwritten NAPLAN assessment is “sensible but is not a substitute for teaching children to write by hand every day.”
“Much more is needed. The Coalition’s policy is to move nationally to an approach where AI and screens are used only if justified by a clear educational purpose. As it stands, some jurisdictions will merely ‘consider’ reducing screen time,” Leeser said.
“The bitter truth is that our academic performance is at its worst level ever, and we need urgent interventions.”
However, Jason Clare said the long-running argument over whether schools need more money or more reform misses the point.
“The truth is we need both, and that’s what the agreements we have signed with every state and territory are all about," Clare told The Educator. “[We're] tying that funding to the things we know work to teach kids how to read and write and count."
Clare also pointed to an agreement by education ministers to "a big structural change" to drive this reform.
“This is something that’s been talked about for a long time but has never happened," he said. “Bringing under one roof a body – the Australian Teaching and Learning Commission – that’s responsible for the national curriculum, national testing, national teacher standards, teacher training and research."
What does good evidence look like?
Professor Ken Purnell, Head of Educational Neuroscience at CQUniversity, has spent more than three decades turning brain science into something teachers can use in the classroom. His work covers memory, behaviour, self-belief and wellbeing, and his free online courses have drawn more than 52,000 learners from around the world.
He says the Australian Schools Digital Detox Taskforce should look beyond screen-time figures to assess whether the changes are improving academic performance, concentration, student engagement, wellbeing and independent thinking.
So what should the Taskforce be measuring instead? Professor Purnell said the answer lies in looking at learning from more than one angle, starting with the data schools already collect.
“Good evidence comes at two levels. The first is quantitative data that is fairly accessible: improvements in NAPLAN, PISA and TIMSS results, alongside school and schooling authority records of attendance, behaviour and wellbeing surveys across the various states and territories,” Professor Purnell told The Educator.
The second level, said Professor Purnell, is what teachers and students observe.
“This includes longer concentration spans, greater engagement with learning tasks, genuine participation – not just filling a seat – and students clearly thinking for themselves and doing the hard neurological work that results in learning, rather than outsourcing it to a chatbot,” he said.
“Schools and schooling authorities that report to the Taskforce from various trials will provide nuanced data, which is far superior to any single figure. It is a wicked real-world problem that defies simplistic answers.”
Professor Purnell noted that even encouraging patterns need to be treated with caution and have “repeated, clear evidence.”
“For example, PISA 2022 found that up to an hour a day of device use for learning was linked with higher maths scores, but the link turned negative beyond that, and it did not show cause and effect,” he said, adding that other uncontrolled factors may have contributed to the positive result.
“The people best placed to judge what works are the students' teachers. Guidelines need to inform teachers’ professional judgement in their specific context, not replace it.”
Beyond the headlines on handwriting
Professor Purnell said the return to handwritten Year 5 NAPLAN writing provides an opportunity to reconsider the balance between traditional and digital learning methods.
“Both keyboarding and handwriting have their place, and one can be better for learning than the other,” he said. “For example, a 2024 meta-analysis of college students found a small achievement advantage for handwritten notes, yet typing produced far more notes.”
Professor Purnell pointed to a widely reported Norwegian brain study, which also favoured handwriting. In the study, participants typed with one finger, and no learning was tested, so a later commentary judged its classroom claims too strong.
“The commentary did not question the value of handwriting itself. So, everyday keyboarding and everyday handwriting need more research: what works best, when, for whom, and under what conditions?” he said.
“Working memory holds only about four chunks at once. Handwriting forces selection, which protects that limited capacity. Typing frees capacity for composing and editing and may favour certain writing processes.”
Why an IT expert went back to pen and paper
Professor Purnell said he strongly recommends an appropriate mix of handwriting and keyboarding, depending on the learning task and educational goals.
“An expert IT colleague at CQUniversity uses sophisticated digital pens and software. Yesterday he asked me, ‘Ken, you notice how I’m taking notes these days?’” he said. “He now writes by hand because the software led him down too many rabbit holes, and he wants only the key points.”
Professor Purnell said this builds schemas in the brain (cognitive constructs at the ‘big picture’ level) that his colleague can then drill into easily.
“In this case, taking meeting notes for future actions, keyboarding with first-tier software and agents led to too many distractions instead of focused attention on what matters,” he said. “We are reminded that the tool should fit the task. We lose if we treat either method as the answer to every task.”
The office of Federal Education Minister Jason Clare has been contacted for comment.