The case for balance in NAPLAN’s pen and paper pivot

The case for balance in NAPLAN’s pen and paper pivot

From 2028, NAPLAN will be returning to a pen and paper test for Year 5 students in a bid to curb excessive screen use, improve attention, and lift educational outcomes in classrooms.

The decision, inked at the Education Ministers Meeting on Monday 2 November, follows recent data showing that while NSW Year 5 students edged ahead of the national average in writing, nearly one-third still fell below the expected standard.

NSW Education Minister Prue Car, who had been advocating for the move ahead of the meeting, said teachers, principals, and parents had voiced concerns that online testing in primary school does not reflect the fact that most classroom learning takes place offline.

“The evidence from our classrooms points clearly to the ongoing value of handwriting and its importance for student development and engaging a different way of learning,” Car said. “We’re listening to teachers and families who want a sensible, balanced approach to technology use in schools.”

For many teachers, the decision simply confirms what they have long seen in their own classrooms. But returning to handwriting is not without its trade-offs, and the shift raises questions that reach well beyond how NAPLAN is run.

So what can pen and paper tell us about a student’s thinking that a screen can’t, and what do we risk losing by going back to it?

Dr Tianchong (Alex) Wang, a Senior Lecturer in STEM in Innovative Education Futures at Flinders University, researches the use of AI in education, educational innovation, digital equity and assessment.

He said pen-and-paper and screen aren’t rivals.

“Both have real value, and they do their best work at different points in a child’s learning,” Dr Wang told The Educator. “Bloom’s taxonomy, the ladder of thinking most teachers know, is a useful way to see it.”

‘You can’t climb a ladder with the bottom rungs missing’

Dr Wang said the foundations of remembering, understanding and applying the basics are at the base, while analysing, evaluating and creating are at the top.

“Pen and paper help build the base. For young children, forming letters and numbers by hand is part of how they learn them,” he said. “Research links handwriting with stronger letter recognition, spelling and early reading, and links fine hand skills with early maths.”

A pen-and-paper task shows us how secure those foundations are, De Wang said.

“When those basics become automatic, the mind is free for bigger ideas,” he said. “You can’t climb a ladder with the bottom rungs missing.”

Dr Wang said digital assessment comes into its own when tasks demand more than memorising facts.

“The further up the ladder we go, the more it offers,” he said. “Students can show their thinking in many forms, from writing and speaking to video, design or code.”

Dr Wang said tasks can be interactive and closer to real-world problems – specifically, the kind that call for analysing, evaluating and creating.

“Work can be gathered over time, so we see growth and not just a single snapshot. And teachers can see how a student got there, not only where they ended up, which turns assessment from a verdict into a conversation,” he said.

“Done well, digital also gives every student more than one way to take part and to express what they know, including those with special needs, learning difficulties or different ways of learning. That is technology in the service of access, equity and inclusion.”

Dr Wang said that this way, each student can work through a task in the way that suits them, teachers can target support where it is needed, and students can see their own progress and act on it.

“Assessment stops being only a measure of learning and becomes part of it,” he said. “That is why balance matters.”

Dr Wang said the real task is to be deliberate.

“Decide what kind of thinking we want to see, then choose the tool that shows it best,” he said. “Purpose first, tool second.”

The best of both worlds: a four-step guide

Moving forward, Dr Wang said a digital detox for schools is an opportunity to move towards a more purposeful, developmentally appropriate approach to technology in education.

“Schools now have a rare opportunity to step back and ask what meaningful use of technology looks like, and what in learning must be protected,” he said, pointing out that this is not screens against paper. “The goal is the best of both worlds, with technology used where it deepens learning and never for its own sake. As the saying goes, adding wings to a caterpillar does not make a butterfly.”

Dr Wang said four questions can guide the way.

“First, who is doing the thinking? Research keeps pointing the same way. Time on a screen tells only part of the story. What students do with that time tells us far more,” he said. “Technology that does the thinking for a student takes the learning with it.”

Dr Wang said technology that makes a student question, compare, explain and create can deepen that thinking.

“This matters most with AI,” he said. “A tool that hands over the answer and a tool that asks a better question are very different things in a classroom.”

The second question, said Dr Wang, is ‘does it fit the learner’s stage?’

“Protecting the basics and building digital literacy are not competing goals,” he said. “They are two lanes of the same road.”

Dr Wang said young children need most of their time on the foundations, with technology “brought in carefully and with purpose.”

“Older students need more room to use digital and AI tools well, and critically, because that is the world they are walking into. The lanes run side by side,” he said. “What changes with age is the balance between them.”

Third, said Dr Wang is the question of what informs the choice.

“Good decisions about technology are not made on fear of missing out, or on what everyone else is doing,” he said. “What works in one school cannot be copied and pasted into another.”

Dr Wang said the better path is to stay agile.

“Start from what the research shows, try an idea on a small scale, look closely at what it does for students, then refine it or let it go,” he said. “This is action research, and it turns teachers and leaders from adopters of technology into investigators of it.”

Done well, the result is transformative, said Dr Wang.

“It is not the same lesson with a screen attached, but learning that has changed for the better.”

The fourth question, said Dr Wang, is who benefits, and on whose terms.

“Access to a device is only the start. What matters is what students get to do with it,” he said. “Some use technology to create, question and solve problems, while others mostly use it to consume.”

Dr Wang said meaningful use closes that gap, so that every student, including those with special needs and those from disadvantaged backgrounds, gets the kind of use that stretches their thinking.

“As for the terms, they should be education’s own, set by learners’ best interests and teachers’ professional judgement, not by commercial pressure or the momentum of the technology itself,” he said. “Technology should serve people, not the other way round.”

Dr Wang cautioned that these choices cannot rest on individual teachers alone.

“Leaders set the direction with a shared view of what technology is for, and back it with time to plan and professional learning,” he said, adding that leaders also keep asking what is working, what is not, what has been learned, and what is helping or holding things back.

“Do this, and the use of technology stops being a default and becomes a thoughtful decision.”