
High-achieving students fear their academic edge is being eroded. Nearly two-thirds of secondary students admit their peers use chatbots to complete homework. And more than half of teachers now back a temporary ban on take-home assessments. The AI integrity crisis in Australian schools is no longer a future problem — it is already here.
Gradeo surveyed 200 New South Wales schools for a report cited in The Australian. It found 61% of high-performing students believed AI was undermining their ability to stand out. Around 91% of teachers said detection was no longer enough; assessment itself needed to be redesigned.
About 53% backed a temporary ban on take-home tasks while schools adapted.
How NSW is responding to AI and take-home assessments
“Take-home activities have always been vulnerable to outside influence, particularly large creative projects. They have always had a bias towards privileged middle class kids,” Tom Alegounarias, former chair of the NSW Education Standards Authority, said.
Alegounarias also said at-home tasks were conceived as a pressure valve for exam stress. The effect had been the opposite, pushing schools back toward in-person testing to protect the integrity of Year 12 results.
Schools in Years 11 and 12 are now limited to one take-home assessment task, worth no more than 7.5% of a student’s total Higher School Certificate (HSC) mark. The move came after authorities found that AI was linked to more than 1,000 cases of exam cheating in 2025.
What does AI mean for the future of take-home assessments?
The concern cutting through the data is not just academic dishonesty — it is cognitive development. Natasha Fox is director of teaching at St Clare’s College in Sydney, New South Wales. She said students who relied on chatbots to generate ideas were stunting their own learning. “Students need to be able to think under pressure,” she told The Australian. “If they haven’t engaged with the content, they won’t be able to show their knowledge.”
Fox noted a common assumption: that students are technology-literate simply because they game or shop online. In reality, many lack the knowledge to use AI ethically.
St Clare's College has responded by shifting toward oral assessments, written exams, and greater emphasis on handwriting. The goal is to embed AI as a thinking partner rather than a finishing tool.
At Concord High School in Sydney’s inner west, principal Victor Newby said assessment integrity concerns were apparent at least four years ago. “Students who were tracking for a C or D level were submitting final works at an A level," he said. “That’s when we started using spoken assessments as a validation step."
How should principals redesign assessment in the AI era?
The practical response requires school leaders to act on structure, not just policy. A principal’s guide to keeping AI honest in the classroom outlines how leaders must create structured opportunities for teachers to test and reflect before scaling AI use across a school.
Federal Education Minister Jason Clare has backed more in-class assessments. He pointed to research showing students performed better on homework using AI but worse in exams. “That’s pretty good for productivity, not good for learning,” he said.
For school leaders, the central challenge is redesigning learning environments so AI supports understanding rather than replaces it. The structures built around take-home assessments now will determine whether genuine learning — not just AI-assisted output — remains at the centre of Australian schooling.