
For all the shocking revelations to emerge from some of the nation’s most wealthy private schools in recent months, not one has had its funding reduced or suspended over serious misconduct under current laws.
New legislation introduced by the Greens aims to change that.
In a statement on Wednesday, the Greens said the new bill would force Labor to act on misconduct and unethical behaviour by giving the Federal Education Minister the power to cut the funding of offending schools.
The Minister can already withhold or suspend funding under the Education Act, but the Act’s “fit and proper” rules don’t require them to weigh immoral or unethical behaviour, serious neglect or poor governance.
However, the Greens’ proposed ‘Accountability and Transparency for Private Schools’ Bill would close that gap, requiring the Minister to consider these breaches when deciding whether a school keeps its Commonwealth funding or has it reduced or suspended.
A double standard on funding?
“Elite private schools have been given a blank cheque by governments for far too long,” Greens spokesperson on primary and secondary education Senator Penny Allman Payne said in a statement.
“While Labor keeps the public school system underfunded, it continues to give money hand over fist to wealthy fee-charging private schools, who operate by their own rules with barely any accountability and transparency.”
Allman Payne said departmental inquiries into private school misconduct have repeatedly come to nothing.
“Our current standards have let schools like Redeemer Baptist receive millions in public money while engaging in outrageous conduct,” she said. “These standards clearly aren’t working.”
Allman Payne said the Greens were done waiting for Labor to hold private schools to account.
“The Minister has the power to use public funding as a lever for genuine change but he refuses to use it. If Labor won’t act, the Greens will force their hand,” she said.
“It’s time we set a higher standard for our kids’ education. Public money should not unconditionally fund systemic misogyny, harassment or abuse.”
'Student safety shouldn’t depend on the sector'
Graham Catt, CEO of Independent Schools Australia, said there could be no exceptions where safety is concerned.
"Any allegation of abuse, harassment or serious misconduct must be always taken seriously, and no school or system should be beyond scrutiny," Catt told The Educator. "All students, staff and school communities deserve to have serious concerns properly investigated."
Catt noted that Independent schools are already accountable to the Australian Government and other regulatory bodies.
"State education authorities already have powers to investigate misconduct and impose sanctions, including funding consequences where there are breaches in certain cases," he said. "The Greens should know that."
Catt said that if The Greens are genuinely concerned about student safety, they would be proposing evidence-based policy to apply to all schools regardless of sector.
"Instead, with unsubstantiated claims, emotive language of elitism and privilege – ignoring the fact that the majority of affected schools are low to mid-fee schools serving low to middle income families – this seems like another ideologically driven political stunt rather than a serious attempt to protect students and the community."
The fine print of 'fit and proper'
The Department of Education, for its part, says the existing legislative framework already gives it scope to act on concerns about a school’s conduct and governance.
“The department, through the Australian Education Act 2013 and the Australian Education Regulations 2023, has broad powers to act on fitness and propriety concerns,” a Department of Education spokesperson told The Educator. “Existing fit and proper requirements empower the department to consider patterns of immoral or unethical behaviour and poor governance at schools.”
The distinction between the two positions is a subtle but important one. The Department says existing requirements empower it to consider such conduct. The Greens’ bill, by contrast, would require the Minister to take these breaches into account when deciding whether a school’s Commonwealth funding is maintained, reduced or suspended.
“The department exercises these powers as a matter of course, supporting schools to remedy issues and taking firmer actions, such as the imposition of conditions and changes to funding, where persistent or more serious circumstances are seen,” the spokesperson said, adding that jurisdictions and schools are responsible for the day-to-day operation of schools, and the Department "does not comment on the specifics of active compliance matters."
“Where there are compliance concerns, the department works closely with state and territory education departments and other regulatory authorities, taking action where non-compliance is identified."
The spokesperson added that Australian Government recurrent funding for all schools is calculated with reference to each school’s Schooling Resource Standard (SRS).